Pen Paper & Ink
Search /
Comparison · fountain pen

Pilot Custom 74 vs Pilot Custom 823

Pilot Custom 74 or Pilot Custom 823? The almanac scores both, attribute by attribute. The marked cell wins each row.

On the measures the almanac scores, Pilot Custom 74 leads 2 rows to 1. Read both, then choose for your own use.

Pilot Custom 74

The most affordable way into a Pilot 14k nib, in a light smoke demonstrator.

Pilot Custom 823

A workhorse dressed as an heirloom: vacuum-filled, generously inked, and quietly engineered for the page.

Pilot Custom 74Pilot Custom 823
Nib material Gold 14k Gold 14k
Nib size M M
Flex Soft Soft
Feedback Soft tooth Smooth
Takes ink Cartridge or bottle Bottle only
Filling system Cartridge/Converter Vacuum (vac-fill)
Converter Pilot CON-70 converter —
Capacity 1.1 ml 2 ml
Flow Wet Wet
Body material Resin Acrylic
Weight capped 20 g 29 g
Max diameter 14.5 mm 14.5 mm
Length capped 143 mm 149.5 mm
Length uncapped 125 mm 131 mm
Cleaning ease Easy Difficult
MSRP (USD) $270.00 $360.00
Street price $216.00 $416.00

On the measures the almanac scores, Pilot Custom 74 leads 2 rows to 1. Read both, then choose for your own use.

— Pen Paper & Ink

Common questions

Is Pilot Custom 74 or Pilot Custom 823 better?

Pilot Custom 74 leads on the measured attributes, 2 rows to 1, on the 3 attributes the Pen Paper & Ink almanac scores directionally. A lead in the count is not a recommendation: the rows measure different things, and which of them matters depends on how you write. The clearest differences: Feedback (Soft tooth vs Smooth), Takes ink (Cartridge or bottle vs Bottle only), Filling system (Cartridge/Converter vs Vacuum (vac-fill)), Capacity (1.1 ml vs 2 ml).

What is the difference between Pilot Custom 74 and Pilot Custom 823?

Feedback: Pilot Custom 74 Soft tooth, Pilot Custom 823 Smooth. Takes ink: Pilot Custom 74 Cartridge or bottle, Pilot Custom 823 Bottle only. Filling system: Pilot Custom 74 Cartridge/Converter, Pilot Custom 823 Vacuum (vac-fill). Capacity: Pilot Custom 74 1.1 ml, Pilot Custom 823 2 ml. Body material: Pilot Custom 74 Resin, Pilot Custom 823 Acrylic. Weight capped: Pilot Custom 74 20 g, Pilot Custom 823 29 g. Both are fountain pen specimens held in the Pen Paper & Ink almanac, measured on the same 17-attribute scale.

What is the Pilot Custom 74 like?

The most affordable way into a Pilot 14k nib, in a light smoke demonstrator.

What is the Pilot Custom 823 like?

A workhorse dressed as an heirloom: vacuum-filled, generously inked, and quietly engineered for the page.

Pilot Custom 74 in full → Pilot Custom 823 in full → Open the live comparison → Browse all pens →