Pen Paper & Ink
Search /
Comparison · fountain pen ink

Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi vs Noodler's Black

Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi or Noodler's Black? The almanac scores both, attribute by attribute. The marked cell wins each row.

On the measures the almanac scores, Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi leads 4 rows to 2. Read both, then choose for your own use.

Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi

A true black with the slight warmth of charcoal. The universal solvent of Iroshizuku.

Noodler's Black

The original bulletproof black - cellulose-bonding, fraud-resistant, archival.

Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumiNoodler's Black
Hue Black Black
Warmth Neutral Neutral
Family Standard Bulletproof
Saturation 92 / 100 95 / 100
Wetness 64 / 100 60 / 100
Sheen 3 / 5 0 / 5
Shading 2 / 5 1 / 5
Shimmer 0 / 5 0 / 5
Feathering 1 / 5 1 / 5
Bleed 1 / 5 1 / 5
Show-through 1 / 5 2 / 5
Dry · M nib 18 s 24 s
Water resistance None Bulletproof
Lightfastness 3 / 5 5 / 5
Permanent No Yes
Bottle 50 ml 90 ml
Price / ml $0.64 $0.19

On the measures the almanac scores, Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi leads 4 rows to 2. Read both, then choose for your own use.

— Pen Paper & Ink

Common questions

Is Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi or Noodler's Black better?

Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi leads on the measured attributes, 4 rows to 2, on the 6 attributes the Pen Paper & Ink almanac scores directionally. A lead in the count is not a recommendation: the rows measure different things, and which of them matters depends on how you write. The clearest differences: Family (Standard vs Bulletproof), Saturation (92 / 100 vs 95 / 100), Wetness (64 / 100 vs 60 / 100), Sheen (3 / 5 vs 0 / 5).

What is the difference between Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi and Noodler's Black?

Family: Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi Standard, Noodler's Black Bulletproof. Saturation: Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi 92 / 100, Noodler's Black 95 / 100. Wetness: Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi 64 / 100, Noodler's Black 60 / 100. Sheen: Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi 3 / 5, Noodler's Black 0 / 5. Shading: Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi 2 / 5, Noodler's Black 1 / 5. Show-through: Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi 1 / 5, Noodler's Black 2 / 5. Both are fountain pen ink specimens held in the Pen Paper & Ink almanac, measured on the same 17-attribute scale.

What is the Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi like?

A true black with the slight warmth of charcoal. The universal solvent of Iroshizuku.

What is the Noodler's Black like?

The original bulletproof black - cellulose-bonding, fraud-resistant, archival.

Pilot · Iroshizuku Take-sumi in full → Noodler's Black in full → Open the live comparison → Browse all inks →